Tag Archives: Avoid simplistic or overly broad questions such as “What is a loophole?” or “Define win-win transactions.” Questions like these will receive little to no credit.

Win-win Transactions

Type a set of five questions and answers that reflect your understanding of the concepts of facts, win-win transactions, loopholes, and line drawing.

Your test will be graded on your ability to create thought-provoking, practical examples and demonstrate deep engagement with the material. Be sure to follow these guidelines carefully.

 

What to Do:

1. Create Five Original Questions (20 Points Each):
   • Write one question for each of the following concepts:
     • Facts: Focus on how legal decision-makers determine “what happened” in a case.
     • Win-Win Transactions: Explore situations where all parties seemingly benefit and the legal or ethical boundaries of such agreements.
     • Loopholes: Investigate gaps in laws or rules and how they can be exploited or closed.
     • Line Drawing: Examine how courts, lawmakers, or individuals draw boundaries to resolve complex legal issues.
   • Write a fifth question that ties together two or more of these concepts.
2. Draft and Explain the Correct Answer (and Incorrect Answers):
   • For each question, provide an answer key.
   • Explain in 3-5 sentences why your answer is correct.
   • Explain why the other choices are incorrect.
3. Cite Readings and Class Discussions:
   • Use examples, principles, and authors we’ve studied in class to support your answers.
   • Draw from readings like Kenneth Arrow on incentives, Saul Levmore on legal innovation, and Michael Pardo on proof.

Grading Criteria:

• 20 Points per Question (100 Points Total):
  • Creativity & Practicality (10 points): Does your question reflect real-world complexity? Does it require thoughtful application rather than simple recall?,
  • Clarity (5 points): Is the question clear and well-written?,
  • Correct Answer Explanation (5 points): Does your explanation demonstrate depth and reference course materials?

Important Notes:

• Avoid simplistic or overly broad questions such as “What is a loophole?” or “Define win-win transactions.” Questions like these will receive little to no credit.,
• Be practical: Think of scenarios that a lawyer judge or policymaker might actually encounter.,
• You’re welcome to reference hypothetical scenarios or current events to inspire your questions.

Example:

• You may wish to create a question about a company’s creative interpretation of tax laws (loopholes) or a scenario where facts are disputed in a courtroom. Be sure to focus on the legal reasoning process and the consequences of these situations.