Justice & Identity Reflections

1) In Letter from Birmingham Jail, King distinguishes between just and unjust laws. Looking at today’s world, what is one law, policy, or social norm you think could be considered “unjust” in King’s terms? Explain why you think so, and how civil disobedience or other forms of activism might be used to address it.

2) W.E.B. Du Bois described “double consciousness” as the struggle of seeing oneself through both one’s own eyes and through the eyes of a prejudiced society. Do you think people today still experience something like “double consciousness”? If so, give a modern example (racial, cultural, gender, or other identity-based). If not, explain what has changed since Du Bois’ time.

3) In What to the Slave is the Fourth of July?, Frederick Douglass argued that the holiday highlighted freedom for some while ignoring oppression for others. Can you think of a holiday, tradition, or national narrative today that feels inclusive to some groups but excluding or painful to others? How should society handle such tensions?Justice & Identity Reflections

In Letter from Birmingham Jail King distinguishes between just and unjust laws. Looking at today’s world what is one law policy or social norm you think could be considered “unjust” in King’s terms? Explain why you think so and how civil disobedience or other forms of activism might be used to address it.,
W.E.B. Du Bois described “double consciousness” as the struggle of seeing oneself through both one’s own eyes and through the eyes of a prejudiced society., Do you think people today still experience something like “double consciousness”?, If so give a modern example (racial cultural gender or other identity-based)., If not explain what has changed since Du Bois’ time.,
In What to the Slave is the Fourth of July?, Frederick Douglass argued that the holiday highlighted freedom for some while ignoring oppression for others. Can you think of a holiday, tradition, or national narrative today that feels inclusive to some groups but excluding or painful to others? How should society handle such tensions.

Comprehensive General Responses

1️⃣ King — Unjust Laws Today

In Letter from Birmingham Jail, Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. argues that unjust laws are those that degrade human personality, restrict basic rights, or are applied unequally. In today’s world, one policy that could be viewed as unjust through King’s lens is restrictions on voting access that disproportionately affect marginalized communities. Laws requiring specific IDs, reducing polling locations in certain neighborhoods, or limiting mail-in ballots can create barriers that silence particular groups rather than represent them.

Civil disobedience and activism—such as organized voter registration campaigns, peaceful demonstrations, court challenges, and public awareness initiatives—align with King’s philosophy of nonviolence to confront injustice. These actions highlight moral urgency, pressure change, and promote a more equitable democratic process.

2️⃣ Du Bois — Double Consciousness Today

W.E.B. Du Bois’ concept of double consciousness remains relevant. Many people still navigate the tension of seeing themselves through both personal identity and the judgments imposed by society.

For example, Black professionals may feel pressure to modify speech, appearance, or behavior to fit expectations of a predominantly white workplace—maintaining pride in cultural identity while simultaneously managing how others perceive them.

Similarly, LGBTQ+ individuals might constantly assess how open they can be in different environments due to assumptions, stereotypes, or safety concerns.

These modern forms of double consciousness show that while society has progressed, people from marginalized groups still experience the psychological strain of living in spaces where their identity is both celebrated and scrutinized.

3️⃣ Douglass — Exclusion in National Celebrations

Frederick Douglass argued that Independence Day celebrated freedom for white Americans while ignoring the ongoing enslavement of Black people. Today, a comparable example is Columbus Day. For many, it symbolizes exploration and national heritage, yet Indigenous communities often view it as a celebration of colonization, violence, and cultural erasure. What feels patriotic to one group can represent trauma to another.

To handle such tensions, society can:

Reevaluate narratives to include historically silenced voices.
Educate about multiple perspectives rather than glorifying a single version of history.
Shift celebrations, such as replacing Columbus Day with Indigenous Peoples’ Day, honoring resilience and contributions.

Blog