Gig Worker Status
Jamie works as a makeup artist for several entertainment companies in Atlanta. For the past 3 years, she has provided makeup services for performers at Harmony Productions, a regional performing arts company. Harmony has always classified Jamie as an independent contractor. They do not withhold taxes, provide benefits, or allow her to unionize. Jamie sets her own schedule, brings her own makeup supplies, and works for other clients.
Recently, Jamie learned about the 2023 Atlanta Opera case, where the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) ruled that makeup artists and other stagehands at the Atlanta Opera should be classified as employees, not independent contractors, making them eligible for unionization. The NLRB applied a new worker-friendly test that emphasized workers’ entrepreneurial opportunity and their dependency on the employer.
Jamie and several other makeup artists are now considering challenging their classification at Harmony Productions, believing that they might qualify as employees under the new standards set by the Atlanta Opera case. Harmony insists that Jamie and her colleagues are true independent contractors who have significant control over their work and entrepreneurial opportunities.
Please read this article: Government Scrutiny of Gig Workers Is Misplaced.
Then, please discuss the following with your peers:
- What key factors do you believe might determine whether Jamie should be classified as an employee or an independent contractor under the new standard?,
- What are the potential benefits and risks for gig workers who are reclassified as employees?,
- What broader implications might the Atlanta Opera case have for the gig economy and labor relations in the United States? Gig Worker Status,
-
What key factors do you believe might determine whether Jamie should be classified as an employee or an independent contractor under the new standard?,
-
What are the potential benefits and risks for gig workers who are reclassified as employees?,
-
What broader implications might the Atlanta Opera case have for the gig economy and labor relations in the United States?
✅ Comprehensive General Response
Jamie’s situation reflects the ongoing national debate about gig worker status. Under the new NLRB standard highlighted in the Atlanta Opera ruling, classification focuses heavily on entrepreneurial opportunity, degree of economic dependence, and control in the working relationship.
To determine whether Jamie should be categorized as an employee, key factors would include:
-
Level of control by Harmony Productions (e.g., how her work is directed or supervised)
-
Integration of her role into the company’s core business (is makeup essential to performances?)
-
Ability to independently market her services and set rates
-
Dependency for income (does Harmony supply the majority of her revenue?)
-
Use of her own tools, supplies, and schedule autonomy
-
Ability to take on other clients without restrictions