Hi, How Can We Help You?
  • Address: 1251 Lake Forest Drive New York
  • Email Address: assignmenthelpcentral@gmail.com

Tag Archives: Do the study’s author(s) use surveys secondary data or some alternative method of data collection?

August 20, 2024
August 20, 2024

Research Methods in Criminal Justice

Operationalizing variables is an important part of many studies when a phenomenon cannot be observed directly. Although a physical variable like a person’s height or Orlando’s average temperature during the month of February can be directly measured, social science research frequently requires us to investigate social or theoretical constructs that can only be indirectly captured with carefully designed methods. In criminal justice research, for example, measures of socio-economic status could be measured at the individual-level or in the aggregate; they often incorporate education, income, employment, home ownership, and neighborhood of residence. A more “theoretical” example is a construct such as self-control, which incorporates components such as temper, impulsivity, and risk-seeking that are typically measured at the individual-level using surveys.

Research Methods in Criminal Justice

Consider a variable of your choice that appears in published criminal justice research which represents some social construct, rather than being observed directly. Then, locate two peer-reviewed journal articles from criminology/criminal justice that feature this variable.

Research Methods in Criminal Justice

  • Discuss how this variable is operationalized in each of the two example articles you have selected. In your paper, ensure you comment on the following:
  • What elements or components combine to represent this construct? (Consider the SES and self-control examples mentioned above.)
  • How is measurement accomplished in your chosen examples? For instance, are the variables captured at the individual-level or the aggregate-level? Do the study’s author(s) use surveys, secondary data, or some alternative method of data collection?
  • What concerns can you identify with the reliability and validity of these approaches to operationalization?
  • Remember to identify the source of your example CJ journal articles using proper APA-style citations, where appropriate.

Research Methods in Criminal Justice

Operationalizing variables is an important part of many studies when a phenomenon cannot be observed directly. Although a physical variable like a person’s height or Orlando’s average temperature during the month of February can be directly measured, social science research frequently requires us to investigate social or theoretical constructs that can only be indirectly captured with carefully designed methods. In criminal justice research, for example, measures of socio-economic status could be measured at the individual-level or in the aggregate; they often incorporate education, income, employment, home ownership, and neighborhood of residence. A more “theoretical” example is a construct such as self-control, which incorporates components such as temper, impulsivity, and risk-seeking that are typically measured at the individual-level using surveys. APA.

June 28, 2024
June 28, 2024

Research Methods – Criminal Justice

To effectively discuss how variables representing social constructs are operationalized in criminal justice research, let’s consider two examples: “perceived neighborhood safety” and “recidivism.”

Perceived Neighborhood Safety

Operationalization

Components

Perceived neighborhood safety combines subjective perceptions of crime, safety, and community trust. It often includes factors like fear of crime, trust in neighbors, and feelings of security.

Measurement

Typically measured at the individual-level through surveys where residents rate their perceptions of safety and crime in their neighborhood. For example, respondents might answer questions about how safe they feel walking alone at night or their confidence in local law enforcement.

Example Article:

Source: Sampson, R. J., Raudenbush, S. W., & Earls, F. (1997). Neighborhoods and violent crime: A multilevel study of collective efficacy. *Science, 277*(5328), 918-924.

Research Methods - Criminal Justice

Research Methods – Criminal Justice

 Operationalization: The authors operationalize perceived neighborhood safety by aggregating survey responses from residents within various neighborhoods. They measure collective efficacy, which includes perceived trust among neighbors and willingness to intervene for the common good, reflecting perceptions of safety indirectly.

Concerns

 Reliability: Subjective perceptions can vary widely among individuals within the same neighborhood, affecting the reliability of aggregated measures.

 Validity: Perceived safety may not always align with actual crime rates, raising concerns about the construct validity if perceptions are not grounded in objective reality.

Recidivism

Operationalization

Components: Recidivism typically includes re-offending behaviors after an initial conviction or incarceration. It encompasses multiple dimensions such as re-arrest, re-conviction, and re-incarceration.

Research Methods – Criminal Justice

Measurement: Often measured at the individual-level using criminal justice databases that track subsequent arrests or convictions. Researchers may also follow up with ex-offenders over time to track their legal statuses.

Example Article:

Source:  Langan, P. A., & Levin, D. J. (2002). Recidivism of prisoners released in 1994. *Bureau of Justice Statistics Special Report*. U.S. Department of Justice.

Operationalization:  The study operationalizes recidivism by tracking a cohort of released prisoners and documenting subsequent arrests and convictions over a specified follow-up period, typically through criminal records and official databases.

Concerns

Reliability: Variations in law enforcement practices and reporting can affect the reliability of recidivism rates reported in different jurisdictions.

Research Methods – Criminal Justice

Validity:  Narrow definitions of recidivism (e.g., focusing only on re-arrest rather than re-conviction) may limit the construct validity of how well recidivism reflects actual criminal behavior.

In both examples, operationalization involves translating abstract concepts into measurable variables using specific methods like surveys or criminal justice records. However, concerns about reliability and validity are crucial due to the subjective nature of perceptions (e.g., neighborhood safety) and the variability in legal definitions and enforcement practices (e.g., recidivism). These factors must be carefully considered in interpreting and comparing findings across studies. APA.