HCMG 4901 – Article Critique. Reviewing a Scientific Paper. The article assigned for this critique is “Environmental Determinants of Quality of Life in Nursing Home Residents with Severe Dementia ”
If there are several parts to a question, you must answer all parts to receive complete credit.
- For each answer, use parenthetical citation to cite the article, section of the article, and page number where you found the information in the article, e.g., (Garre-Olmo, et al., 2012, Discussion, p. 1234)
- Each question is worth 10 points.
- Please provide the APA style Reference section citation for this article. (See Content Module 3.)
- What institutions do the authors represent?
- How was this research funded? Did the sponsor have any role in the research process?
- Is a conflict of interest statement included? What does it say?
- What ethical procedures are mentioned? What organization provided ethical approval? What information is given about informed consent? HCMG 4901 – Article Critique.
- Are clear research objectives stated? What is the objective of this research?
- Was the research done with people? If so, please identify the target population.
- What type of research design was used?
- What is the setting of the data collection?
- Are there inclusion criteria? If so, list them here.
- Are there exclusion criteria? If so, list them here.
- What type of sampling was done? Briefly describe the sampling process.
- What was the sample size? Why was this sample size chosen? Was a power analysis conducted?
- How were the data collected?
- Why were proxy respondents used? What information was collected about the proxy respondents?
- What are the independent variables? How were they measured?
- What is the dependent variable? How was it measured? (Give a brief description of the instrument used to measure the dependent variable.) What reliability measures are presented for the dependent variable? Are any validity measures presented?
- Did the research use control variables to address potential confounding? Please list them here.
- What types of statistical analyses were used?
- In one sentence, state the major study finding. HCMG 4901 – Article Critique.
- What are the stated limitations of this research? (Keep in mind that ALL research has limitations. This is not a FAULT in the study. It just gives the reader additional context regarding the findings.)
- What future research should be done? Why?
- How can a nursing home administrator use the information from this study?